Episode 37

Scaling Checkup: Is Your Leadership Fit for the Future?

Most CEOs don’t plan their own exit. What happens when the person who built the company isn’t the right one to scale it?

Scott Calderwood joins Maartje van Krieken to talk about CEO transition strategies, scaling leadership challenges, and executive hiring mistakes. When a company reaches a breaking point—whether at Series C funding, IPO, or another growth stage—how do leaders know if they’re still the right fit? And more importantly, what happens when they aren’t?

Scott shares hard-earned insights from decades in executive search, and reveals why cultural fit matters as much as technical skill in leadership hires. He introduces the “bad hire calculator,” a tool that puts real numbers behind the cost of hiring the wrong person. With firsthand stories of leadership transitions gone right (and wrong), this episode is a must-listen for leaders going through the realities of executive growth and change.


Episode Breakdown:

00:00 Leadership Challenges in Modern Business

01:24 CEO Replacement Dynamics

03:45 Recognizing the Need for Leadership Change

05:10 Cultural Fit in Leadership Roles

09:46 Challenges in Leadership Transition

12:44 The Cost of a Bad Hire

16:10 Interim Solutions for Leadership Gaps

18:10 Trust and Cultural Fit in Teams

20:29 Entrepreneurial Spirit in Small to Mid-Sized Companies


Links

Connect with Scott Calderwood:

Website: https://calderwoodsearch.com/

E-mail: scott@calderwoodsearch.com


Scott Calderwood, President and CEO of Calderwood Search Partners Inc., is a seasoned executive recruiter and sales expert with 30 years of experience in corporate and entrepreneurial roles. He specializes in mid-to-senior-level placements in technical sales and marketing, managing executive, director, and managerial searches.


Known for his professionalism and client-focused approach, Scott builds long-term relationships by delivering tailored solutions and exceptional service. Under his leadership, Calderwood Search Partners has become a trusted talent partner across the U.S. and Canada, aligning top talent with company culture and business needs.


Connect with Maartje van Krieken:

https://www.thechaosgamesconsulting.com/

https://www.linkedin.com/in/maartje/

https://maartjeturnschaosaround.substack.com/



Podcast production and show notes provided by HiveCast.fm

About the Podcast

Show artwork for The Business Emergency Room Podcast
The Business Emergency Room Podcast
Triage, Tools & Tactics to recover from or prevent business chaos in this VUCA business environment

About your host

Profile picture for Maartje van Krieken

Maartje van Krieken

Maartje van Krieken is a crisis strategist, executive consultant, and your at host of The Business Emergency Room podcast, where growing businesses go when things get messy. With a career that began in frontier oil and gas and spanned war zones, boardrooms, and billion-dollar pivots, Maartje has spent over two decades helping organizations steer through chaos and come out stronger.
Now through her consulting firm, The Chaos Games, Maartje works with medium-sized businesses, especially those scaling rapidly or navigating uncertainty, to diagnose breakdowns in leadership, collaboration, and decision-making before they become business emergencies. Her signature approach blends practical triage, people-first strategy, and blunt Dutch honesty to help teams realign fast.

​The Business Emergency Room delivers high-impact insights for business leaders, board members, and investors who are tired of the symptoms, disconnection, friction, paralysis, and want the tools to fix what’s really going wrong. Maartje’s episodes cut through fluff with stories, frameworks, and metaphors that turn even the most complex chaos into something leaders can act on.
Maartje is based in New Orleans and speaks regularly on navigating organizational storms, building business resilience, and turning reactive firefighting into proactive leadership. Whether you’re scaling a business, running a team, or dealing with dysfunction, The Business Emergency Room is the place to find straight talk and smarter tools.